Saturday, June 18, 2011

Tommy Revisited

Recently saw the Tommy movie this evening, and I am reminded why I didn't like it:

  • Ken Russell represents everything that is bad about the 70s.
  • Tommy worked better in the abstract: the scenes where Tommy is tortured, drugged, and molested are horrifying.
  • The album was set post WW1, which gave it some distance from contemporary society, but still attached it to an era of disruptive change.
  • Ann Margaret, the mother, is about Roger Daltry's age: the beach scene is creepy.
  • Speaking of Ann Margaret, the Who performed Tommy at Woodstock with Hendrix and Janis, and Ann Margaret performed with Elvis in Viva Las Vegas: there's an insurmountable culture gap that leaves the movie looking for an audience.
  • One improvement over the album was having the mother's boyfriend kill the father.

2 comments:

Steve said...

That's the problem with Russel. He doesn't mind if he offends you or thrills you as long as his films get a reaction.
I Have to agree with you that Tommy missed the mark. Looking back the film wasn't about Tommy, but how Russel didn't like the lower class. I felt they had cheapen the country up.
To give Russel his due, I did like the his movie The Devils and enjoyed The Lair of the White Worm.

Steve said...

Oops: Second para last sentence should be: He felt...